Best Pizza on Anna Maria Island: Local’s Guide – Perfect Slice

Whether you’ve just spent the day dolphin sightings on a Crysten’s AMI Boat Tour or you’re just checking into your vacation rental, one thing is certain: you’re going to want pizza.

Anna Maria Island (AMI) may be small, but it is packed with incredible pizzerias. To help you find your perfect slice, we’ve rounded up every major pizza shop on the island, plus our favorite “over-the-bridge” gems.

Located on the famous Pine Avenue, this is the place for artisan, stone-fired pies.

• The Vibe: Modern, bright, and trendy. Great for a quick lunch while shopping.
• Style: Thin, crispy, handcrafted crust with unique toppings.
• Address: 308 Pine Ave, Anna Maria.

A local staple known for its “thin and crispy” square-cut style.

• The Vibe: Very casual and family-friendly.
• Style: Cracker-crust style that is light and perfect for a beach snack.
• Address: 308 Pine Ave (Shares space/history with Pizza Social).

While it’s a full-service restaurant, their gourmet pizzas are some of the best-kept secrets on the island.

• The Vibe: Casual fine dining—perfect for a nice family sit-down.
• Style: Fresh, high-quality ingredients with a thicker, doughier crust option.
• Address: 5406 Marina Dr, Holmes Beach.

If you need variety and reliability, Pizzano’s is a powerhouse in Holmes Beach.

• The Vibe: Great for carry-out or a quick casual bite.
• Style: Known for their “Detroit Style” deep dish and famous garlic knots.
• Address: 5318 Marina Dr, Holmes Beach.

Often called “Little Italy,” Vinny’s is an authentic Italian market and pizzeria.

• The Vibe: Upscale deli/market feel.
• Style: Authentic Italian wood-fired taste.
• Address: 5337 Gulf Dr, Holmes Beach.

A hidden gem in the Anna Maria Island Shops plaza.

• The Vibe: A local “hole-in-the-wall” that doubles as a sports bar.
• Style: Traditional hand-tossed pies.
• Address: 3244 East Bay Dr, Holmes Beach.

An island legend right across from the beach.

• The Vibe: Bustling, old-school, and full of character.
• Style: Large, cheesy New York and Sicilian style slices.
• Address: 201 Gulf Dr N, Bradenton Beach.

Located just over the south bridge on the North End of Longboat Key.

• Why go: For high-end, artisan Italian pizza in a beautiful wine-bar setting.
• Address: 6814 Gulf of Mexico Dr, Longboat Key.

A few miles east on Cortez Road, this is where the locals go when they want to escape the island crowds.

• Why go: Incredible homemade meatballs and a crust that tastes like home.
• Address: 7604 Cortez Rd W, Bradenton.

The classic “Welcome to the Island” stop for families coming over the north bridge.

• Why go: They have perfected the New York fold since 1989.
• Address: 7220 Manatee Ave W, Bradenton.

The absolute best way to enjoy an AMI pizza? Order it to-go and bring it on your boat charter! At Crysten’s AMI Boat Tours, we love anchoring at a quiet sandbar while our guests enjoy a hot pie and a cold drink. It’s the ultimate Florida experience.